top of page
Background Image: A whole cake on a plate

MENU

Every item on our menu tells a delicious story.

Order Online

Menu



Hot Coffee & Drinks




Drip Coffee

The classic, morning afternoon or night get our delicious home brewed coffee.

Drip Coffee


Cafe Au Lait

The French seem to know a thing or two about coffee. This is how they start their day!

Cafe Au Lait


Espresso

Single or Double! Nitrous for your veins regardless.

Espresso


Latte

Plain, or flavored. Latte's are a fan favorite

Latte


Caramel Macchiato

2.0oz of greek espresso with foam and delicious caramel drizzle.

Caramel Macchiato


Red Eye

Fresh-brewed coffee with an added espresso shot for an extra kick.

Red Eye


Cappuccino

Classic espresso topped with steamed milk and light foam.

Cappuccino


Flat White

Smooth espresso finished with silky steamed milk and minimal foam.

Flat White


Nescafe

Traditional Greek-style instant coffee, simple and familiar.

Nescafe


Americano

Espresso diluted with hot water for a clean, bold cup.

Americano


Herbal Tea

Harney & Sons tea options: - Chamomile - Green - Peppermint - Earl Grey - English Breakfast - Paris - Darjeeling

Herbal Tea


Chai

Spiced black tea brewed with warming aromatics.

Chai


Chai Latte

Spiced chai blended with steamed milk for a creamy finish.

Chai Latte


Hot Chocolate

Rich, comforting hot chocolate made with steamed milk.

Hot Chocolate


Signature Berry Hot Chocolate

Our house hot chocolate with a subtle berry twist.

Signature Berry Hot Chocolate


Decaf Options

All the flavor of our Drip and Espresso based drinks without the caffeine.

Decaf Options



Iced Coffee & Cold Beverages




Iced Americano

Chilled espresso poured over ice for a bold, refreshing finish.

Iced Americano


Iced Coffee

Fresh-brewed coffee served cold over ice.

Iced Coffee


Cold Brew

Slow-steeped coffee with a smooth, low-acid profile.

Cold Brew


Freddo Cappuccino

A classic Greek/Italian hybrid favorite with whipped espresso and cold milk foam.

Freddo Cappuccino


Nitro Cold Brew

Creamy, nitrogen-infused cold brew with a naturally smooth texture.

Nitro Cold Brew


Iced Latte

Espresso and cold milk poured over ice.

Iced Latte


Iced Red Eye

For the weary and tired, iced coffee boosted with an added espresso shot.

Iced Red Eye


Iced Mochaccino

Espresso, chocolate, and milk served chilled over ice.

Iced Mochaccino


Greek Style Frappe

Traditional Greek iced coffee, frothy and refreshing, with flavor options available. Flavors: Caramel, White Chocolate, Mocha, Chocolate Banana, Hot Chocolate

Greek Style Frappe


Frappe Float

Greek-style frappe topped with gelato for a sweet, creamy finish

Frappe Float


Affogato

Classic espresso poured over gelato.

Affogato


Iced Chai Latte

Spiced chai blended with cold milk over ice.

Iced Chai Latte


Iced Raspberry Tea

Light and refreshing iced tea with natural raspberry flavor.

Iced Raspberry Tea


Iced Passion Fruit Tea

Bright and tropical passion fruit iced tea.

Iced Passion Fruit Tea



House-Made Milkshakes

Thick, Creamy and made with real gelato.




Chocolate Shake

Rich chocolate gelato blended smooth and creamy.

Chocolate Shake


Vanilla Shake

Classic vanilla gelato shaken thick and cold.

Vanilla Shake


Strawberry Dream Shake

Strawberry gelato blended with berry cookie dough.

Strawberry Dream Shake


Nutella Milkshake

Creamy gelato blended with Nutella.

Nutella Milkshake


Caramel Sea Salt Shake

Caramel gelato blended smooth with a hint of sea salt.

Caramel Sea Salt Shake


Espresso Shake

Gelato blended with fresh espresso for a bold, creamy shake.

Espresso Shake


Pistachio Shake

Classic pistachio gelato blended rich and nutty.

Pistachio Shake


Mint Chocolate Chip Shake

Mint gelato with chocolate chips blended cool and refreshing.

Mint Chocolate Chip Shake


Cinnamon Toast Shake

Cinnamon gelato with warm cereal-inspired flavor, blended thick.

Cinnamon Toast Shake


Rainbow Cookie Shake

Gelato blended with classic Italian rainbow cookie flavor.

Rainbow Cookie Shake


Cannoli Cream Shake

Gelato blended with classic Italian rainbow cookie flavor.

Cannoli Cream Shake


Raspberry Sorbet Shake

Tart raspberry sorbet blended into a refreshing shake.

Raspberry Sorbet Shake


Mango Sorbet Shake

Smooth mango sorbet with bright tropical flavor.

Mango Sorbet Shake



Pastries

(Available All Day)




Croissants

Buttery, flaky croissants baked fresh daily.

Croissants


Cheese Danish

Flaky pastry filled with sweet cream cheese.

Cheese Danish


Apple Turnover

Golden pastry filled with warm spiced apples.

Apple Turnover


Linzer Tarts

Classic shortbread cookies layered with fruit preserves.

Linzer Tarts


Oatmeal Rasin Cookie

Soft oatmeal cookie with plump raisins and warm spice.

Oatmeal Rasin Cookie


Red Velvet Cookie

Soft red velvet cookie with rich cocoa flavor.

Red Velvet Cookie


Triple Chocolate Cookie

Chocolate cookie packed with three kinds of chocolate.

Triple Chocolate Cookie


Macadamia Cookie

Buttery cookie loaded with white chocolate and macadamia nuts.

Tree nuts
Macadamia Cookie


M&M Cookie

Soft baked cookie filled with colorful chocolate candies.

M&M Cookie


Rainbow Cookies

Traditional Italian almond cake layered with jam and chocolate.

Rainbow Cookies


Macarons

Delicate French almond cookies with assorted seasonal fillings. Options: Vanilla Birthday Cake Pistachio Raspberry Cookies & Cream Dark Chocolate

Gluten free
Macarons


Fudge Brownie

Rich, dense chocolate brownie with a fudgy center.

Fudge Brownie


Oreo Brownie

Fudgy chocolate brownie swirled with Oreo pieces.

Oreo Brownie


Fudge Brownie GF

Gluten-free chocolate brownie with a rich, fudgy texture.

Gluten free
Fudge Brownie GF


Eclair

Classic pastry filled with cream and topped with chocolate glaze.

Eclair


Cannoli

Crisp pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream.

Cannoli


Fruit Tart

Buttery tart shell filled with cream and topped with fresh fruit.

Fruit Tart


Chocolate Covered Strawberries

Fresh strawberries dipped in smooth chocolate.

Gluten free
Chocolate Covered Strawberries


Crumb Cake

Moist cake topped with a thick cinnamon crumb.

Crumb Cake


Muffins

Fresh-baked muffins in assorted daily flavors. Choc Chip Double Choc Bleuberry Corn Cinnamon Chip Cappuchino Carro

Muffins


Mini Pastries

Assorted bite-size pastries perfect for sharing.

Mini Pastries


Biscotti

Traditional twice-baked almond or raisin cookies.

Biscotti



Greek Treats




Baklava

Crisp layers of phyllo, chopped nuts, and syrup, rich without being overwhelming.

Tree nuts
Baklava


Galactoboureko

Creamy custard baked in phyllo and finished with syrup for a smooth, balanced bite.

Galactoboureko


Ekmek Kataifi

Syrup-soaked shredded phyllo topped with custard and cream, rich and indulgent from start to finish.

Tree nuts
Ekmek Kataifi


Kataifi

Crispy shredded phyllo wrapped around nuts and soaked in syrup for a perfectly textured classic.

Tree nuts
Kataifi


Karidopita

Moist walnut cake lightly spiced and soaked in syrup, simple and satisfying.

Tree nuts
Karidopita


Portokalopita

Orange-forward phyllo cake with bright citrus flavor and a soft, syrupy finish.

Portokalopita


Kourabiedes Cookie

Buttery almond shortbread dusted in powdered sugar that melts as you eat it.

Kourabiedes Cookie


Melomakarona Cookies

Melomakarona Cookies – Spiced honey-soaked cookies finished with walnuts, classic and comforting.

Melomakarona Cookies


Koulourakia Cookie

Light, slightly sweet butter cookies baked until golden and crisp.

Koulourakia Cookie


Kok

Small, syrup-soaked pastry puffs filled with rich vanilla pastry cream and covered in a shiny chocolate glaze.

Kok


Fanouropita

Greek vegan spice cake made in honor of Saint Fanourios, the patron saint of lost things!

Vegan
Fanouropita



Cake

It doesn't have to be your birthday to grab a slice of our delicious cake.




Birthday Cake

Birthdays are a time for fun colors and delicious flavors the whole family will enjoy!

Birthday Cake


Black and White Cake

Can't decide between Vanilla or Chocolate. The black and white cake combines both amazing flavors so you don't have to.

Black and White Cake


Carrot Cake

A decadent moist, spiced cake using grated carrots packed with warm spices. Famously topped with a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting.

Carrot Cake


Cannoli Cake

Cannoli cream on cake is marrying two delectable partners for one great experience!

Cannoli Cake


Chocolate Mouse Cake

Decadent high quality chocolate is used for our classic house made chocolate cake.

Chocolate Mouse Cake


Napoleon Cake

Also called the mille fleur. European dessert made of numerous thin, flaky puff pastry layers and a rich, smooth pastry cream filling

Napoleon Cake


Oreo Cake

One of the best cookies, in one of the best cakes, sounds like a combo made in heaven!

Oreo Cake


Red Velvet Cake

Rich, spongey, tangy the red velvet cake is one to try.

Red Velvet Cake


Sugarbbery Cake

Soft vanilla cake layered with fresh berries and lightly sweetened cream.



Strawberry Shortcake

A magnificent combination of fluffy cake, strawberries and cream

Strawberry Shortcake


Tiramisu

A classic Italian dessert made of coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with a rich mascarpone cheese based cream, then topped with a dusting of cocoa powder.

Contains Alchohol
Tiramisu


Truffa Cake

A cake with mixed fresh cream, vanilla, and chocolate, then coated the ganache with melted dark chocolate and rolled it in cocoa powder!

Truffa Cake


Strawberry Tres Leches

An incredibly moist, rich, and tender cake, consisting of a light, airy sponge cake soaked in a sweet mixture of three different types of milk.

Strawberry Tres Leches


Lemon Coconut

Light lemon cake layered with coconut and lightly sweetened cream.

Lemon Coconut



Cheesecake

A certified New York classic.




New York Cheesecake

The certified classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about!

New York Cheesecake


Sugar Free Cheesecake

The certified Sugar Free classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about!

Sugar Free Cheesecake


Carmel Cheesecake

Gooey caramel on great cheesecake is a match made in heaven!

Carmel Cheesecake


Baklava Cheesecake

Adding Baklava to anything is great, especially cheesecake!

Baklava Cheesecake


Chocolate Cheesecake

Rich chocolate in our house made rich creamy cheesecake.

Chocolate Cheesecake


Oreo Cheesecake

One of the worlds best cookies crumbled into the NY Bakery Cafe's signature cheesecake.

Oreo Cheesecake


Red Velvet Cheesecake

Dark and rich red velvet layered with New York style cheesecake.

Red Velvet Cheesecake


Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry filling on top of our world famous cheesecake.

Strawberry Cheesecake


Berry Cheesecake

Tasty, Sweet and Fruity goodness all on our awesome cheesecake!

Berry Cheesecake


Crème Brule Cheesecake

The golden combo, delectable rich caramelized sugar on our famous cheesecake.

Crème Brule Cheesecake



Cupcakes & Cake Pops

Small treats sometimes are the best treats




Vanilla Cupcake

Classic vanilla cupcake finished with sprinkles and vanilla frosting.

Vanilla Cupcake


Chocolate Fudge Cupcake

Rich chocolate cupcake with deep fudge flavor and smooth frosting.

Chocolate Fudge Cupcake


Red Velvet Cupcake

Bite-size red velvet cake dipped and finished on a stick.



Oreo Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake topped with cookies-and-cream frosting and Oreo pieces.

Oreo Cupcake


Elmo Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with bright frosting.

Elmo Cupcake


Strawberry Milkshake Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with strawberry milkshake-style frosting.



Cookie Monster Cupcake

Chocolate chip cupcake topped with cookies-and-cream frosting.



Churro Cupcake

Cinnamon-spiced cupcake finished with sweet churro-style frosting.



Carrot Cupcake

Moist carrot cupcake topped with smooth cream cheese frosting.



Rainbow Cupcake

Colorful vanilla cake topped with smooth frosting, classic and fun.

Rainbow Cupcake


M&M Cupcake

Vanilla cupcake topped with chocolate frosting and M&M candies.



Vanilla Cake-Pop

Classic vanilla cake blended and dipped in chocolate.



Chocolate Cake-Pop

Rich chocolate cake blended and dipped in chocolate.



Red Velvet Cake-Pop

Red velvet cake blended with cream cheese and dipped in chocolate.



Oreo Cake-Pop

Chocolate cake blended with Oreo cookie pieces and dipped in chocolate.



Funfetti Cake-Pop

Vanilla cake mixed with colorful sprinkles and dipped in chocolate.




Hot Items




Bougasta

Traditional Greek pastry filled with warm custard and layered in crisp phyllo.

Bougasta


Croissants

Buttery, flaky croissants baked fresh daily.

Croissants


Spinach / Spanakopita (Pie Slice)

Spinach, herbs, and cheese wrapped in crisp phyllo for a balanced, savory bite.

Spinach / Spanakopita (Pie Slice)


Cheese/ Tiropita (Pie Slice)

Flaky phyllo filled with a rich, savory cheese blend, baked until golden.

Cheese/ Tiropita (Pie Slice)



Pudding

The two P's!




Bread Pudding

A creamy, subtly sweet, and comforting, desert like a mellow, thick porridge made from rice and cream.

Contains Alchohol
Bread Pudding


Creme Brule

Rich custard with a tasty glass like sugar topping. One of the best deserts out there!

Gluten free
Creme Brule


Flan

A sweet custard desert with a layer of delicious caramel on top.

Gluten free
Flan



Pie by the Slice

Nothing more American!




Pecan Pie

A beloved Southern holiday staple featuring crunchy pecans in a gooey, custard-like filling.

Pecan Pie


Apple Pie

Nothing's as American as Apple Pie, at least the saying goes. Our apple pie is also Homemade!

Apple Pie



Gelato




Pistachio Gelato

Rich pistachio gelato with a smooth, nutty flavor.

Pistachio Gelato


Mint Chip Gelato

Cool mint gelato with chocolate chip pieces.

Mint Chip Gelato


Stracciatella Gelato

Classic vanilla gelato with thin ribbons of chocolate.

Stracciatella Gelato


Rainbow Cookie Gelato

Gelato inspired by classic Italian rainbow cookies.

Rainbow Cookie Gelato


Cannoli Cream Gelato

Sweet ricotta-style gelato with cannoli cream flavor.

Cannoli Cream Gelato


Caramel Sea Salt Gelato

Creamy caramel gelato finished with a touch of sea salt.

Caramel Sea Salt Gelato


Vanilla Gelato

Smooth, classic vanilla gelato.

Vanilla Gelato


Chocolate Gelato

Rich and creamy chocolate gelato.

Chocolate Gelato


Cinnamon Gelato

Warm cinnamon-spiced gelato with a smooth finish.

Cinnamon Gelato


Nutella Gelato

Chocolate-hazelnut gelato blended rich and creamy.

Nutella Gelato


Strawberry Cookie Dough Gelato

Strawberry gelato swirled with cookie dough pieces.

Strawberry Cookie Dough Gelato


Strawberry Banana Gelato

Smooth strawberry gelato blended with ripe banana flavor.

Strawberry Banana Gelato


Raspberry Sorbet

Bright, tart raspberry sorbet with a refreshing finish.

Dairy free
Raspberry Sorbet


Passion Fruit Sorbet

Tropical passion fruit sorbet, light and vibrant.

Dairy free
Passion Fruit Sorbet


Lemon Sorbet

Fresh lemon sorbet with a crisp citrus bite.

Dairy free
Lemon Sorbet


Mango Sorbet

Sweet, tropical mango sorbet blended smooth.

Dairy free
Mango Sorbet



Desert Table




Whole Apple Pie

Nothing's as American as Apple Pie, at least the saying goes. Our apple pie is also Homemade!

$22

Whole Apple Pie


Whole Pecan Pie

A beloved Southern holiday staple featuring crunchy pecans in a gooey, custard-like filling.

$23

Whole Pecan Pie


Whole Raspberry Apricot Pie

Buttery pie filled with sweet raspberries and apricots.

$23

Whole Raspberry Apricot Pie


Whole Coconut Custard Pie

An old-fashioned dessert featuring a rich, creamy filling loaded with sweetened shredded coconut.

$23

Whole Coconut Custard Pie


Whole Blueberry Pie

Gooey sweet blueberry pie filling is always delectable inside our homemade pic crust.

$22

Whole Blueberry Pie


Whole Cherry Pie

Homemade flaky, buttery pastry crust filled with a sweet-tart cherry filling.

$22

Whole Cherry Pie


Whole Apple Crumb Pie

Sometimes known as a Dutch apple pie, it has all the goodness of a classic apple pie with a delicious crumbly streusel topping

$23

Whole Apple Crumb Pie


Whole New York Cheesecake

The certified classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$35


Medium

$45

Whole New York Cheesecake


Whole Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry filling on top of our famous cheesecake. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$40


Medium

$50

Whole Strawberry Cheesecake


Whole Berry Cheesecake

The Sugarberry Special! Tasty, Sweet and Fruity goodness all on our awesome cheesecake! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$40


Medium

$50

Whole Berry Cheesecake


Whole Caramel Cheesecake

Gooey caramel on great cheesecake is a match made in heaven! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$40


Medium

$50

Whole Caramel Cheesecake


Whole Oreo Cheesecake

One of the worlds best cookies crumbled into Sugarberry Cafe's signature cheesecake. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$40


Large

$60

Whole Oreo Cheesecake


Whole Tiramisu Cake

A classic Italian dessert "Cake-fied" made of coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with a rich mascarpone cheese based cream, then topped with a dusting of cocoa powder. Small Serves: 6–8 people

$35

Whole Tiramisu Cake


Whole Red Velvet Cake

Rich, spongey, tangy the red velvet cake is one to try. Small Serves: 6–8 people

$35

Whole Red Velvet Cake


Whole Birthday Cake

Birthdays are a time for fun colors and delicious flavors the whole family will enjoy! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$35


Medium

$45

Whole Birthday Cake


Whole Chocolate Cake

Moist chocolate cake, a light and airy chocolate mousse filling, Topped with a rich chocolate ganache. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$35


Medium

$45

Whole Chocolate Cake


Whole Black & White Cake

Can't decide between Vanilla or Chocolate. The black and white cake combines both amazing flavors so you don't have to. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$35


Medium

$45

Whole Black & White Cake


Whole Strawberry Tres Leches Cake

An incredibly moist, rich, and tender cake, consisting of a light, airy sponge cake soaked in a sweet mixture of three different types of milk. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people

Small

$35


Medium

$45

Whole Strawberry Tres Leches Cake


Whole Carrot Cake

A decadent moist, spiced cake using grated carrots packed with warm spices. Famously topped with a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting. Small Serves: 6–8 people

$35

Whole Carrot Cake


Whole Sugarberry Cake

Soft vanilla cake layered with fresh berries and lightly sweetened cream. Medium Serves: 10–14 people

$47



Small Cookie Platter (1.5lbs)

Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are always a hit.

$29.95

Small Cookie Platter (1.5lbs)


Large Cookie Platter (2.5lbs)

Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are easy to share and always a hit.

$39.95

Large Cookie Platter (2.5lbs)


Gluten Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)

Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are always a hit.

$18.95

Gluten free
Gluten Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)


Sugar Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)

Same great cookies, no added sugar.

$18.95

Sugar free
Sugar Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)


Large Fruit Tart

A beautiful dessert with a crisp, buttery pastry crust, Creamy filling and beautifully arranged fruits.

$35

Large Fruit Tart

bottom of page